Once you understand that the real driver is pepsin and a suppressed repair pathway, the pattern behind every failed treatment starts to make sense.
Acid suppression lowers acid. It does not lift bound pepsin off the throat and it does not turn the repair pathway back on. It treats half of the problem and leaves the other half running in the background.
Alginate rafts physically block reflux events from rising. Useful, sometimes meaningfully so. But the pepsin already embedded in the tissue from previous months of refluxing is still there. The raft works on what's coming up. It does not work on what's already landed.
Low-acid diets reduce the number of times pepsin gets reactivated. This is real and worth doing. It is also a holding pattern. A holding pattern slows damage. It does not rebuild what's already been lost.
And then there's the natural route most people eventually try. Growing broccoli sprouts on the kitchen counter.
The reasoning is sound — sprouts contain the precursor compound the body uses to switch the repair pathway back on.
The problem is the conversion step. The precursor only becomes the active compound when a specific enzyme is present at the moment of digestion.
Most people with chronic reflux do not produce enough of that enzyme reliably. So some mornings the sprouts work. Most mornings they don't. There is no way to know which morning is which.
Generic broccoli supplements have the same gap. Many contain only the precursor, with no enzyme included. Stomach acid breaks the precursor down before it can be converted. The label looks right. The result is silence.
None of these tools are wrong. They are just aimed at the wrong layer of the problem.